armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan
Locked
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

Why Selig Must Resign Today

13
Vote

by user DNL

OnDLsmall.jpg
more "on the DL" opinions

Jason Grimsley has more drugs in him than most rock stars. Uppers, HGH, 'roids, and probably a few things we have never even heard of would appear on his tox screen. And, even though Major League Baseball has a drug testing policy in place -- and has since the start of last year -- the only reason Grimsley isn't pitching is because he suffered from a much different affliction: a loose tongue.

Nevertheless, it's apparent that MLB's drug testing scheme sucks. (It's also apparent that Rafael Palmeiro is mind-bogglingly stupid, having managed to test positive.) The current regime is a farce, a scam, a red herring.

Over the past 18 or so months, Bud Selig has been talking a big game. Here's an article with some great comments, below, demonstrating Selig's public posture:


     
 

[T]he [steroid-testing] programs have kicked in, and we're going to have to do whatever we have to do to eradicate steroids from our sport.


It's not like we've ignored the problem. You can't minimize the health risk. Nobody is taking this lightly.


The objective is to eradicate steroids from baseball. That's the objective. If these programs do that, isn't that what we're supposed to have done? I'm not going to rest until we eradicate steroids. Whatever it takes to get that done, that's what we're going to do.


Now we test year-round, random tests, multiple tests, all the things people had complained about. Am I a little surprised that the new program wasn't at least allowed to work a little bit? We didn't start testing until the 3rd of March. The new program is in force.


Would I like tougher penalties? I would. They asked me about federal legislation. That is something baseball would not object to. This is a subject of collective bargaining. This is the program that we have. At least it's working.

 


All the right things. And, in fact, he said them in March. So, we're on the right path, right?

Nope. He said them in March . . . of 2005. 15 months ago. One full season ago. Now, it turns out that the testing scheme is a joke; that players are using the drugs as much as ever before; and that all Selig's done is turn a blind eye to a growing problem. Indeed, Selig told Congress, bluntly, that the testing regime was the solution: "Let me set one thing straight. I will suspend any player who tests positive. There will be no exceptions."

The trick?

Prevent people from testing positive by looking for the wrong things.

It gets better. In his official statement on the matter, Selig says the following:


     
 

Until this point, I have primarily focused my efforts on trying to eliminate the use of performance enhancing substances from the game. My concerns about the allegations of steroid use among Major League and Minor League players were first and foremost for the health of the players and for the integrity of the game on the field. In 1994, before anybody was really talking about steroids in baseball, we proposed a program of testing for such substances to the MLBPA. As early as 1998, I began formulating a strategic plan to eliminate the use of performance enhancing substances from the game. After consultation with doctors and medical experts, we unilaterally imposed a strict drug testing regimen in the Minor Leagues in 2001. We lobbied vigorously in Congress for the passage of the Steroid Control Act of 2004. We developed and deployed educational programs for minor league players. And, at the Major League level, we achieved the toughest drug policy in professional sports through a series of negotiations with the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA). I am proud of the "three strikes and you're out" policy that we negotiated with the MLBPA. Our joint program gives fans confidence in the integrity of the game on the field.

 


Indeed, Selig once said: "Nobody worries more about the image of the sport than I do. I'm proud of our players."


If that's true, Mr. Selig, save the image of the sport, and step down for someone who will do more than simply "worry."


Update: Benjamin Kabak agrees, but thinks Donald Fehr must go as well. In the comments below, others have expressed a similar sentiment. My take is mixed, as the comments suggest.

Date

Thu 06/08/06, 6:01 am EST

Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
ChristofMVP
1256 days ago
Score 0+-
Selig is not going to resign, so stop hoping for it. From what I have heard, this HGH scandal is going to be far worse than the steroids scandal. That is hard to believe, but I can see it happening. There has been several reports in the regular media discussing the over abundance of uppers in the locker room. One report, I think from SI, said that uppers was much more of a problem then steriods were. Since Grimsley has started to name names, this could get pretty ugly...FAST.

But as far as Bud resigning...not going to happen. Remember, the labor agreement needs to get done this off-season.

On an aside note - MLBPA has until August 15th to decide whether or not to exercise their out option from the current drug testing program. The union would be stupid to do this, but if players left and right are getting busted, I can see that option being exercised.
Permalink | Reply
DNLLegend
1256 days ago
Score -1+-
He'll resign if the clammors get loud enough.
Permalink | Reply
JuTMSY4Legend
1256 days ago
Score -1+-
I absolutely love tis Grimsley thing. If there's a quick way to straighten out everyone this is it. The real question is, if HGH is not detectable, who do you think is on it now? There is also no way Selig resigns without significant pressure (You're right DNL, but its gonna take a lot of pressure). If tying the all-star game doesn't get him, almost nothing will
Permalink | Reply
DNLLegend
1256 days ago
Score 0+-
Tying the All-Star game wasn't his fault. He was left in a bad situation -- tie game, exhibition, doesn't want to blow out some guy's arm.
Permalink | Reply
ThecrookedcapAll-Star
1256 days ago
Score -1+-
They need some new blood at the position. Particularly someone from the outside who will be willing to be tough. After all, the position of commissioner was created in the need to get tough after the Black Sox scandal (and Landis was tough on the offenders). History needs to repeat itself.
Permalink | Reply
CoreyisarealboyMajor Leaguer
1256 days ago
Score -2+-
I think it's possible Selig and MLB know how bad the scandal runs, and had they instated a strict drug policy, I have a feeling we'd be missing an awful lot of superstar players from those lineups every night. If this theory is correct, MLB is faced with a double-edge sword, instate an intense drug screening program and possibly lose big name players, hence losing money, or keep going with this charade in place now and receive utter humility from the feds.
Permalink | Reply
DNLLegend
1256 days ago
Score -2+-
If they implemented a stricter testing policy, they'd not miss anyone, because players would just get clean. Most of the drugs aren't addictive, so the only people who would get caught are those who either irrationally took the drugs, or those who realize that without the drugs, they're basically minor league talent.

But I don't think that either situation would occur. The #1 reasons to take the drugs is to gain a competitive advantage. But at some point, you take the drugs so that you're not at a disadvantage; that is, you're simply keeping up with the Joneses. (Or Sosas, whatever.) We are clearly at that point now. A huge contingent of players are popping pills or taking injections. If the whole game were purged of the drugs, players would demonstrate little change in quality relative to each other.

Permalink | Reply
Sayhey-rodSoccer Kid
1256 days ago
Score 0+-
No doubts he should resign, congressmen do it at the drop of a hat when their philandering ways are exposed; execs resign due their firm's shabby accounting practices. This mess is far worse. But who could takeover? Given the troubles the NFL is having to find a suitable commish...
Permalink | Reply
Sayhey-rodSoccer Kid
1256 days ago
Score 0+-
Report that grimsley was asked to wear a wire in an effort to specifically implicate bonds. This story just keeps getting weirder http://msn.f...tory/5676674
Permalink | Reply
Ray agmJV Squad
1256 days ago
Score 1+-
Someone kidnap Selig and replace him with Stephen Hawking. Not many will be able to tell the difference AND we'll have someone with a brain in place.
Permalink | Reply
DNLLegend
1256 days ago
Score -2+-
When the stuff hits the fan, baseball is going to look worse than awful. I'd not be surprised if the number of players revealed as steroid and/or HGH users is significantly greater than 100. The game's integrity will die. Selig is the only person who can save the game, but it requires that he step down and take full responsibility for the league turning a blind eye. The owners would then have to appoint a commish who will take the drug use issue a lot more seriously. The public line should be "We made mistakes, the era is tainted, but we don't want to ruin the lives of the hundreds of players who were clean, and destroy the fantasy of baseball as America's pasttime. The past is a closet left best closed; in return, we'll give a future that's free of skeletons."
Permalink | Reply
HeatedFish
1255 days ago
Score 0+-
The All-Star game WAS Selig's fault. He ended the game before the home team even got a chance to bat. Not only that, he shouldn't worry about blowing out a guy's arm. Their Major League pitchers, their job is to entertain the fans. That is why and how they get paid. Fire Selig!
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #1
1255 days ago
Score 1+-
While Selig certainly deserves his share of the blame for this atrocious steroids mess, don't forget about the player's union and Donald Fehr. They're arguably more at fault than even Selig. The sad thing is that Selig's record is pretty solid -- he introduced the wild card and interleague play and led baseball to an era of unprecedented attendance growth. All he'll be remembered for, though, is steroids.
Permalink | Reply
DNLLegend
1255 days ago
Score -2+-
The difference is that the player's union (and Fehr) is there to protect the players' interests. It's hard to say that drug testing furthers that interest. The argument could be made either way.
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #2
1255 days ago
Score -2+-
I should of pointed out that Selig couldn't act unilaterally on drugs testing. He never had that power. Everything had to be done with the compliance of the players union. Usually in the CBA. And they had to be dragged kicking and screaming to the bargaining table when it came to steroids testing. Sadly, without congress at their necks, there probably wouldn't even be steroids testing today or it would be very weak like the programs in other sports.
Permalink | Reply
DNLLegend
1255 days ago
Score -2+-
Of course Selig could act unilaterally -- he has the bully pulpit. No, he can't impose drug testing without MLBPA approval, but that being the case, Selig has an obligation to point fingers. He has to say "I want to take blood and run it under a microscope." He has to say that "The only reason we're better off today is because we were so bad off before." He has to get players to talk before the Feds do. (We didn't need a drug test to determine that Jason Grimsley took HGH!) He has to make the case that MLB is right and the MLBPA is wrong. Instead, he says that "no one is treating this lightly" and pronounced victory.
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #2
1255 days ago
Score -2+-
No, as you yourself point out, he can't do anything without the union's approval. He cannot act unilaterally in terms of any drug testing procedures. So what if he has the bully pulpit? Do you really think the players cower in fear at every word from Selig's mouth? Words mean very little if there's no clout behind them. He has no power to subpoena players and get them to talk about steroids. Didn't you see where the players union already instructed the players NOT to cooperate with Mitchell's investigation? The cooperation of the players unions is bad as it is. Now you think if Selig starts ranting and raving and calling them names, it's going to get better? Sorry, but what fantasy land do you live in? I don't think he has to make a case that the players union is wrong either. Most fans familiar with the issue know that. And believe me, I'm not calling Selig an angel here. He's as much to blame for this too. There's probably more he could have done. But his hands were really tied when it came to drug testing.
Permalink | Reply


Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Why_Selig_Must_Resign_Today"

This page was last modified 22:50, 31 July 2006. Content is available under the GFDL.

Categories: Opinions | MLB Opinions | Steroids Opinions | Barry Bonds Opinions | Bud Selig Opinions | Jason Grimsley Opinions | June 8, 2006 | Opinions by User DNL

Contribute

ArmchairGM's pages can be edited.
Is this page incomplete? Is there anything wrong?
Change it!

Edit this page Discuss this page Page history

Recent contributors to this page

The following people recently contributed to this article.

Embed this on your site

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise