armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

Under Siege from ESPN

7
Vote

by user Kkfla737

Under Siege

The ESPN Hype Machine is doing its best to finish the Miami Program off.

It has been a bad year for the University of Miami Athletic Department. The Football program is underperforming and in shambles, the Basketball team failed to meet expectations and the Baseball team was on probabtion. (though the reached the College World Series.) Things however got much worse for the Miami Athletic Department on Saturday Night as the now infamous melee with cross town rival Florida International took place on the field of the venerable Orange Bowl.

Florida International's fans and players came into the Orange Bowl Saturday night spoiling for a fight and they certainly caused enough trouble for the cross town Canes to last a lifetime. Many F.I.U. players grew up UM fans and are still bitter that they didn't get an offer to play at UM. Many F.I.U. students are upset they didn't get accepted to UM, and the FIU administration led by President Modesto (Mitch) A. Maidique is bitter that they are in the same town as UM. I am told that when President Maidique stumbles across a student wearing UM merchandise on the West Miami Dade FIU campus, he raises holy heck. Miami never should have played a school full of envious, bitter elements, but alas the damage has now been done. (I find it interesting that in its reporting ESPN has yet to mention that Florida International is already on NCAA probabtion for Football practice violations.)

No question exists that Miami's players acted in a fashion that brings great embarrassment to the University, its alumni and to its fans. In addition, I agree with the media critics who state that while Florida International was clearly the aggressor, Miami bears much of the responsibility because their players did not have the maturity to simply walk away when provoked.

Miami should punish all players involved and revoke the scholarships of former Frosh All American Anthony Reddick, and All-American Brandon Merriweather the two most flagrantly misfits the other night. However, Miami should not be subject to any of the inane suggestions and over hype that have floated on the ESPN family of networks in the past few days.

ESPN's commentators seem to forget that schools like Southern California, Tennessee, South Carolina, and Florida State have had far more off the field incidents which actually involved hurting innocent people and reflected poorly on student athletes than Miami has over the past ten years. In fact Miami has had exactly one scholarship player arrested in the past 5 seasons and that player never had charges filed against him. On the other hand, Tennessee had 24 player arrests in the last 20 months! And what about Florida State and Florida, Miami's two in state rivals? As a Florida alum and Gator fan I can truly say that the Ron Zook era in Gainesville was far worse from a discipline standpoint than the Larry Coker era in Coral Gables. As far as Florida State is concerned Bobby Bowden allowed both Ernie Sims and AJ Nickleson to play last season after they had committed violent crimes. But all of this is not important to the commentators on ESPN who simply want to hype what seems to be a big story.

ESPN has ruined College Football in so many ways. Whether it is over hyping of certain matchups and teams or totally destroying the proud legacy of ABC Sports, which for years was the flagship network of College Football, ESPN has been at the forefront of destroying objective thoughtful coverage of the game. For whatever reason, ESPN has had a chip on its shoulder with regards to the Miami program for a few years now. When ESPN's commentators have useful suggestions about how to make College Football a better game we should listen, but when the excercise selective memory and lack objectivity we should turn them off.


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
TartanVarsity Captain
1140 days ago
Score 1+-
Off the field incidents are far different than on-field ones. I firmly believe it is not the university's role to punish off-field happenings, that is what the judicial system is for. However, when something like this occurs in the middle of a game, its shows not the individuals, but the entire program's utter lawlessness. The spectacle was disgusting and abhorrent, and have no place in our society, let alone on a football field. The sheer numbers involved raises this from an individual suspension by suspension issue into a team wide disciplinary process.
Permalink | Reply
TartanVarsity Captain
1140 days ago
Score 1+-
Furthermore, its very irresponsible to drag the names of the other insitutions through the mud in conjunction with this incident. None of those teams have any players that have attempted to murder someone with a very lethal weapon during a game. Please edit your article to either explain how each of these institutions have been worse, or remove them from your post.
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #1
1140 days ago
Score 0+-
Tartan, I understand your point but I respectfully disagree. If a program continues to have players that create harm to others in society isn't that in many ways as bad if not worse than what happened Saturday Night? South Carolina and Clemson players were attacking police officers and security during their brawl. At least Miami and FIU left their fighting amongst players. If Miami should be shut down as many suggest, so should FIU who is already on NCAA probabtion and South Carolina and Clemson. I do not agree with double standards based on perception but that are not grounded in fact. Florida State failed to suspend Ernie Sims and AJ Nickelson after both were charged with violent crimes against defenseless victims. Florida suspended Channing Crowder for a single game after he and Jarvis Herring wielded a gun at police officers, those who put their lives on the line to protect US! I'm not even going to get into Tennessee because they have had so many off the field incidents that bring great shame to a fine academic institution I cannot keep track. Ohio State allowed Maurice Clarett to play in the Fiesta Bowl even though he had been out of class for sometime. If you want more evidence of this double standard, I can post more......Miami was wrong and ought to be punished, but so should these other schools who clearly cannot police themsleves and give College Football a bad name.
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #1
1140 days ago
Score 0+-
That's actually me kkfla737. I forgot to log in.
Permalink
Jogators11
1140 days ago
Score 2+-
Let's clear up one thing. Crowder was suspended for two games although Zook picked which games and they were against our two weakest opponents.

I agree that a double standard exists. Miami should be forced to suspend all 13 players for a minimum of 2 games and they need to fire Larry Coker. But a double standard is clear. Tennessee can send guys like Leonard Little and Dwayen Goodrich on to the NFL after they showed a pattern of reckless behavior at Tennessee and allow them to seriously hurt innocent people and families. Tennessee has had so many players do terrible things in public that make all football players look bad, and yet has recieved little if any scrutiny from the NCAA.

Miami has a mess to clean up, but it is not nearly as bad as some other programs like Tennessee and yes Southern Cal.
Permalink | Reply
TartanVarsity Captain
1140 days ago
Score 1+-
There is a difference in grouping some of these teams together. Ohio State for one, Maurice Clarrett didn't do anything illegal by not attending class and having a tutor help him. The NCAA did not find anything wrong with it either in their investigation. Troy Smith accepting $500 from a booster and not playing in two games was an NCAA violation. However accepting money certainly isn't along the same lines as a brutal attack against a cross-town team. But remember, $500 = two games, one of the them a bowl game. Miami is suspending its players for 1 game for physically assaulting players. Tennessee I agree has had its issues, I don't think Ohio State should be lumped into this group. They had one player, name escapes me, caught with marijuana on campus, and he was booted from the team. This kind of lawless behavior, curiously enough, seems relegated to one region of the country. Players brandishing weapons (why you need a gun as a "student athlete" is beyond me), multiple on field street fights, everything. The SEC/ACC needs to reassess the type of players its recruiting, and moreso, this should show people what type of young men their region is producing. Yeah, they might be able to play football, but living in society appears much more difficult. Players get suspended one game for missing practices or classes, attacking the other team should warrant more penalties. And don't forget, Ohio State was in the same boat a few years ago, many fans thought ESPN was single handedly trying to bring down the program. Maybe its a good omen for UM.
Permalink | Reply
TartanVarsity Captain
1140 days ago
Score 1+-
crap
Permalink
Kkfla737Soccer Kid
1140 days ago
Score 0+-
Point well taken regarding Ohio State. They were fingered by ESPN also for relatively minor problems when compared with FSU and Tennessee. I'll remove Ohio State from "the list."
Permalink | Reply
IcemanvtWaterboy
1140 days ago
Score 0+-
As someone who doesn't have cable, could you please come up with examples of how ESPN is out to get U-Miami?


Unless you have something to back up your assertions, there's no way that you can blame ESPN for the downfall of U-Miami's football program. Miami has brought this upon themselves with their attitude and swagger and in a poor attempt to get that swagger back, they pick a fight with a team they should've mopped the floor with. The fight is inexcuseable, and focusing on the media coverage just looks past how much this program has gone downhill the past couple of years.


And the title of "Under Siege..." is very approprate for a school that thinks of themselves as soldier-warriors, when in fact, they're pampered athletes.
Permalink | Reply
EroosterMajor Leaguer
1139 days ago
Score 0+-
Miami has had the "Bad Boy" reputation for years, that is nothing new. But, I think that the punishment in this case fits the crime. The Miami players did not start the brawl, but rather defended their teammates, at least initially. However, the gross offenders should be punished with at least two games. The FIU players involved should receive the big sentences for this melee. But, who is FIU in the national spotlight? Nobody big. But because it is UM, they get the most national focus.
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #2
1139 days ago
Score 0+-
I totally get the Tennessee thing! I am no Miami fan, hate them in fact and yes they do carry themseleves like thugs in both college and the NFL. But Miami has nowehere near the problems USC and Tennessee do. In fact, I would agree with you. Suspend or terminate all of the instigators for both Miami and the other school and move on. It's not like Fulmer recieved nearly the scrutiny he deserved and quite frankly USC is the new Miami, an inner city based team that is breaking rules and collecting championships with big money boosters like Snoop Dog who nicely fits the Luthar Campbell role hanging around. Miami isn't clean by any measure but they aren't nearly as dirty as USC and others either.
Permalink | Reply
Manny StilesMajor Leaguer
1139 days ago
Score 1+-
There's an easy way of getting around whatever issues ESPN provides you... CHANGE THE CHANNEL!!! We get plenty of "Let's bitch about ESPN" articles ont he 'chair and very few "ESPN does what they do and I accept it" articles
Permalink | Reply
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free


Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Under_Siege_from_ESPN"

This page was last modified 00:25, 18 October 2006. Content is available under the GFDL.

Contribute

ArmchairGM's pages can be edited.
Is this page incomplete? Is there anything wrong?
Change it!

Edit this page Discuss this page Page history

Recent contributors to this page

The following people recently contributed to this article.

Embed this on your site

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise