armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

The Easiest Part of a Coach's Job

17
Vote

by Coachcarpenter

The cuts.

I wish I had Coach Homer Simpson's philosophy of cutting - you, you, you and you are cut. The rest of you made the team. Except you, you and you - you are cut.

Cutting isn't any fun at all. Yesterday, we made cuts for our 7th grade basketball team. Most of the cuts were easy in that there was little doubt the player was not one of the twelve best trying out. None of them were easy in that a kid's heart is getting broken.

7th grade cuts are the worst ones of all because they are the first cuts for most kids. What did Cat Stevens sing about the first cut being the deepest? I think he was writing about his 7th grade basketball experience.

This is the first time some of them realize they are not very good. Of course, some don't realize it even when they are let go. There is shock, tears, anger and bitterness. I still have ill feelings for Marvin Smith, the man who cut me from my 7th grade team and kept Josh Keiser instead. It is troubling to think I will be the focus of several people's anger in the coming years when they think about being cut.

You might imagine that the kids look around and see that they are not very good. Well, they don't. If one lay-up managed to go in, that is the one they remember. If one jumper banked in for three, that is enough to make the squad. It takes a special kid to look around and realize he is not one of the better ones out there.

The ones who do realize they aren't any good often don't stick around for the actual cuts. Many will cut themselves, usually with an excuse about concentrating on homework or not having parental permission. After we did sprints at the end of Thursday's tryout, a kid came up to us and said, "My mom doesn't want me to play this year." His mom had not had time to see him between the 90 minutes he tried out and the time of his explanation, but we didn't bother to call him out on it. We told him that was a tough break and he could hopefully try again next year.

There will likely be parent complaints about some part of the process as well. Last season, a high school player's father emailed our coaching staff about his son who had been cut. Of course, we got the usuals about his up-side, how he was better than some who had made the team and about how it was not fair for some contrived reason. He also mentioned that family reunions would now be sad affairs whenever basketball was brought up. That was a new one.

Competitive scholastic sports might be the first real dose of reality for many people. Up until now, these kids have been told they were special. I remember how my granddad used to brag about my golf skills when we made our way around Eastgate's par 3 course. I was the next Nicklaus. Then I tried out for the golf team and realized he had been full of crap.

Frankly, that is a good word to describe making cuts. It is crap. It keeps you up at night and makes you hurt. It makes you angry at a kid who is stupid enough to think that if he hustles from drill to drill, you won't notice that his shots never hit the rim. It is crap. Thankfully, it is now over.

Until next year.

(Originally posted on the Scenic City Sportsblog at http://chriscarpentersblog.blogspot.com/.  Chris Carpenter is a history teacher and basketball coach in Chattanooga, TN)


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
ASwaffAll-American
768 days ago
Score 4+-
That was a great Simpsons moment, but you left out my favorite part. "I didn't cut everyone I wanted to cut, but I did cut a lot of you."


In all seriousness, though, good article. I never had to deal with being cut, as I pretty much cut out on sports before it got that competitive. But this was a good look at that world.
Permalink | Reply
Steel TownDraft Pick
768 days ago
Score 5+-
I went to a school that didn't cut anyone. Although the B-ball team only had 12 slots, everyone was on the team, but only 12 got to dress on gameday. Same went for the wrestling team I was on. 13 weightclasses but we had a team of over 40 wrestlers. Some guys who would have been cut end up working there way into the lineup and those who don't want to put forth the effort end up cutting themselves like you mentioned. The system left those on the fringe with some hope and gave coaches the opportunity to get a second, third, fourth... look at those players. All in all I think it was a great system.
Permalink | Reply
BOMBERSDiv-I Stud
768 days ago
Score 0+-
If it is run that way then I don't have a problem with it. However if it is run the way my daughters middle school runs it then it is a waste of time. They don't cut anybody and split all of them up into three or four different teams and put one or two good players per group. This frustrates the good players because the ones that are just doing it because their friends are there do not know what they are doing.
Permalink
Interceptor79Varsity
768 days ago
Score 1+-
More schools should run it this way. If they don't dress for matches then it really doesn't cost the school anything yet they still gain the sports booster money. As the kids practice certain ones WILL get better and possibly end up knocking someone from their position. It is competition within competition. I don't like that other idea about making more teams and dividing up the good players...you are right it's stupid
Permalink
CoachcarpenterJV Squad
768 days ago
Score 0+-
At least as far as basketball is concerned, gym space can make keeping everyone nearly impossible. I taught at a school with one gym that kept everyone who wanted to play. We often had to split the gym, have late practices or sometimes no practice. There is a practical question at many schools.
Permalink
Steel TownDraft Pick
768 days ago
Score 0+-
The amount of gyms could have a huge impact. My school had 4 gyms and 3 wrestling rooms. My high school looked more like a college campus. As far as splitting up the teams, if you spread around the good players no one can have a good team. When I was in middle school we had 4 soccer teams, but they were tiered so one team was great and the other was pretty bad. But once again some players bumped out someone from the other team every once in a while. I was on the 3rd tier and was offered to move up to the second tier but why would I do that when I was playing every minute of every game at the level I was on. I found the playing time to be more beneficial than raising my level of competition.
Permalink
Tyrone BriggsHall of Famer
768 days ago
Score 2+-
What exactly do you say to a 7th grader in this situation?
Permalink | Reply
CoachcarpenterJV Squad
768 days ago
Score 4+-
It isn't easy. Most coaches I know like to tell the Michael Jordan story about getting cut in high school. For me, I got cut in 7th grade and made the team as an 8th grader, so I relay that story. I usually tell them that nothing would make me happier than to see them play next year, so do your best to prove that I was wrong to let you go. In the end, it usually doesn't matter what you say because after the words, "I'm sorry," they just want you to shut-up so they can go cry without embarrassment. I did make the mistake my first year of being too specific with someone about why they did not make it. The young man had gotten angry about the team having to run sprints at the end of a hard tryout practice. I told him that part of the reason I picked someone else was his attitude in that circumstance. Big mistake. I had an angry mom yelling at me about how stupid that was and how he was not the only one, etc. It is usually best to be vague and invite them to come back later to ask about areas of improvement when they are not hurting so badly. Some do, most don't.
Permalink
MECUVarsity
768 days ago
Score 0+-
Perhaps in the moment it's best to be vague, but if they come back seeking information on how they can improve, it would probably be better to tell them. Though, the mom overreacting gives a clear picture: You not only cut the kid, you cut the mom, and sometimes that's a more important cut.
Permalink
LASportsblogAAA-er
768 days ago
Score 0+-
I was only cut once, from my college soccer team freshmen year, I was recalled 2 months later though and ended up as the teams #2 so that wasn't really like a cut, I remember it hurting when I got the letter though. As a high school coach I have only been the first team coach, not the manager for the soccer program, so while I make decisions on which players stay, I haven't had to tell them yet. I actually look forward to it because it's a part of life I'm going to have to deal with as a coach and if I don't get proficent in dealing with it.
Permalink | Reply
LASportsblogAAA-er
768 days ago
Score 0+-
I could do more harm then good
Permalink
MECUVarsity
768 days ago
Score 2+-
Challenge doesn't build character, it reveals it. What you do after you get cut is a bigger reflection of who you are as a person than making the team and your performance.
Permalink | Reply
ASwaffAll-American
768 days ago
Score 0+-
Challenge CAN build character, but you have to have some character to start with. You have to have the character to recognize the challenge as a growth opportunity and then make the most of it. But challenges can still build character.
Permalink
Falcon02520Legend
768 days ago
Score 1+-
Cutting players is always a hard thing to do... It destroys many children's view on the sport and in some cases leads them to ingore the sport all together...
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #1
756 days ago
Score 0+-
g
Permalink | Reply
Cougar2000All-American
733 days ago
Score 0+-
Well, Tyrone, you tell them the truth, even though it will hurt. Kids today have to be challenged and getting cut from a sports program or the cheerleading squad is preparation for real life down the road. Coach Carpenter, you didn't make a mistake. That kid showed his butt and you made him an example of what can happen when you let the students run things, rather than the adults.
Permalink | Reply
Cougar2000All-American
733 days ago
Score 0+-
That which does not kill you will strengthen.
Permalink | Reply
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free


Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/The_Easiest_Part_of_a_Coach%27s_Job"

This page was last modified 14:47, 25 October 2007. Content is available under the GFDL.

Contribute

ArmchairGM's pages can be edited.
Is this page incomplete? Is there anything wrong?
Change it!

Edit this page Discuss this page Page history

Recent contributors to this page

The following people recently contributed to this article.

Embed this on your site

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise