armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

Perfect 8 Team Playoff System For College Football

5
Vote

by user Jdsgafflin

It seems so simple to me.

Eight team playoff consisting of six conference champions (BCS Conferences) plus two at large teams. At large teams and seeding shall be determined by a selection committee akin to the NCAA basketball selection process. This team should be made up of former players and other football people instead of writers/coaches. Current polls and computers are such a huge part of the problem, I'd like them scrapped or just used as reference tools for the committee.

First four games can be played at neutral sites or (for those that complain about travel and other logicstical issues) allow the higher seeds to host the first round games. Either way you are going to have four stellar matchups to kick things off. The games could be played New Years Day (or I might recommend playing them in early December in place of conference championship games or the week after). Use existing bowls if it makes things easier on the powers that be.

Then you have a Saturday with 2 semis and a national title game the week after. Only four colleges have their post-season expanded beyond one game and you really don't need the final date of the season to run beyond the current Jan 8.

The first round this year might look like this:

(1) OSU (8) Wake Forest

(4) USC (5) LSU

(2) Florida (7) Oklahoma

(3) Michigan (6) Louisville

I think it's rock solid but would love to hear why you might think otherwise.

Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
Dukeboy999Varsity Captain
1107 days ago
Score 0+-
D-UMB! No offense but this has been offered 100 times before, and thats only in the last month. Plus this system is flawed. How is it fair to Wisconsin who finished 7th in the BCS but third in their conference to miss out. While a team like Wake who was 16th gets a playoff spot. Under this system teams still get screwed. The key to a playoff system is not awarding teams for winning conferences because some years power leagues are weak. Such as the ACC, which was a joke this year. It should just be the top 8 teams. Wow, I just wrote a better blog in this comment than you did in this post. (Hope you dont mind that in turn I take credit for your votes)
Permalink | Reply
Jdsgafflin
1107 days ago
Score 0+-
Please. Gotta bring some knowledge to the table if you are going to respond like that. Saying that the 3rd place team in the Big 10 is more worthy than the ACC champ is exactly the sort of subjective judgement that should be eliminated from the discussion. Wisconsin is the perfect example playing only one ranked team all year and getting beat, yet somehow you view them as better or more deserving than other teams with the same record that played totally different schedules. Eliminate the guessing. You want in? Win your conference. Or earn your way in by separating yourself as an at large team, which Wisco had every chance to do and failed by losing to Michigan. Some team in any system will claim they are getting screwed, that doesn't go away (I guess you think #9 every year will be happy about it in your system) in any system. At least this way the ground rules are clear and everyone knows what it takes along with adding a heightened intensity to all conference games.
Permalink
CoreyisarealboyMajor Leaguer
1106 days ago
Score 0+-
That said, Wisconsin was one win away (or a good second half away considering the two teams were tied 10-10 at halftime) from playing Ohio State for the national championship. Do you really think they should be excluded entirely just because of that one loss? Both of USC's losses came against unranked opponents, does that mean they should be excluded too? Fact is, Wisconsin beat the teams they should have beaten and loss to the one team they possibly should've lost to. They took care of business where USC couldn't. Tell me again why Wisconsin should be forgotten?
Permalink
Anonymous Fanatic #1
960 days ago
Score 0+-
fuck u
Permalink
Dukeboy999Varsity Captain
1107 days ago
Score 0+-
Ok, who was the second ranked team in the ACC? Oh thats right, unranked. Game set match.
Permalink | Reply
TartanVarsity Captain
1107 days ago
Score 1+-
Won't work. The gap between the have and have nots in college football will only expand. Each one of these games worth about 12 million, the major conferences will get every dime. Boise St goes undefeated and doesn't get anything for their troubles. Say Michigan meets Ohio State in the final, which could be quite possible, each team will have earned most likely over $40 million dollars for the playoff process alone. This simply won't work for economic reasons
Permalink | Reply
TartanVarsity Captain
1107 days ago
Score 0+-
Furthermore, a playoff system would almost certainly jeapardize the NCAA's non-tax paying status on its revenues. The BCS is about the closest system it can have and still claim a tax-exempt status, and even that is questionable. A playoff system such as above with blatant attempts at making more money, even if it is in deciding a national championship, would certainly void that coveted status.
Permalink
CoreyisarealboyMajor Leaguer
1106 days ago
Score 0+-
Wisconsin must get included or this playoff system is just as flawed. It's about taking the best teams according the rankings, not according to conference standing. If you want Wake Forest in, create a 16-team playoff.
Permalink | Reply
Manny StilesMajor Leaguer
1106 days ago
Score 0+-
So, we do a playoff for a championship and end up with:
  1. Ohio State - Florida
  2. Ohio State - Michigan
  3. Louisville - Wake Forest (because the good teams all beat each other up...)

So no matter WHAT happens someone gets screwed (for instance you screwed undefeated Boise State)

Everybody just quit the bitching and watch the damned games... Oh yeah, they're kids playing GAMES!!!
Permalink | Reply
False ProphetAll-Star
1106 days ago
Score 0+-
Mine diddn't truely screw anyone. And I still will watch the games, but hope for change.
Permalink
DouglasvgibbsWaterboy
1080 days ago
Score 0+-
With any playoff system, someone always feels they got left out. In this case, what about Boise State? Strength of Schedule may be weaker, but they are undefeated, and has proven themselves by beating Oklahoma. Undefeated is undefeated.
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #2
771 days ago
Score 0+-
balls
Permalink | Reply
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free


Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Perfect_8_Team_Playoff_System_For_College_Football"

This page was last modified 18:59, 12 December 2006. Content is available under the GFDL.

Contribute

ArmchairGM's pages can be edited.
Is this page incomplete? Is there anything wrong?
Change it!

Edit this page Discuss this page Page history

Recent contributors to this page

The following people recently contributed to this article.

Embed this on your site

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise