armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

NHL Suspends Yet Another Flyer

11
Vote

by MetsJetsDevils

On Saturday, Rawbeezeitz profiled the vicious hit from behind laid on Patrice Bergeron by the Flyers Randy Jones.  Bergeron laid unconscious on the ice for several minutesuntil he was carried off on a stretcher.  He suffered a broken nose and a concussion.  Jones apologized for the hit after the game.

After watching the video of the hit, I said that the hit was clearly from behind.  It was not one of those situations where the player turned right before the hit. I certainly think it was a penalty and probably worthy of a five minute penalty and a game misconduct.  While I didn't think it warranted a suspension, I theorized he could end up with a 1 or 2 game suspension in part because of the Flyers history in this season so far.

Turns out I was right.  Today, the NHL suspended their third Flyer of the season, suspending Jones for 2 games.  After reading ESPN's analysis, I have to say that I agree with everyone involved.  First, I agree with Flyers GM Paul Holmgrem whose basic point was that this type of hit, while clearly deserving a major penalty, happens often in this game and has rarely resulted in such a suspension.  The major factor here was the injury to Bergeron.

I also agree with Colin Campbell, the NHL disciplinarian who handed down the suspension because, as I said on Sunday, Jones should have known better.  Bergeron was in a vulnerable position and Jones had plenty of time to process that fact and to adjust.  You see it all the time.  A player lines a guy up, sees he has his back turned, and lets up giving him a little shove instead of smashing him into the boards.  This is exactly what Jones should have, and didn't do.

Finally. I agree with ESPN Analyst Scott Burnside who says that the Flyers have to held accountable for the fact that their players are seemingly out of control.  There is no doubt in my mind that Jones is suffering the penalty for the fact that the season is barely 10 games old and a Flyer has now knocked out two players for a significant amount of time with illegal, regardless of intent, hits.  Add to that the vicious stick assault of Ryan Kesler and the league is faced with a dilemna.  Is it possible that these three incidents are simply coincidence, or are the Flyers being encouraged to this style of play? 

Burnside suggests that it is the later and that the NHL has to take action against the team itself and the coach.  I am not sure I go that far, but he does have a point.  The Flyers have lost 3 guys whose contribution to the league and the Flyers is hard hitting, some good scraps, and very little in terms of offense.  Meanwhile, the three players assaulted are all contributing or even important offensive producers.  I query whether the league can take enough action against the Flyers to prevent someone going after Simon Gagne or Daniel Briere.  Every team has a Jesse Boulerice type player that "finishes" his checks.  I don't think the league would have much sympathy if the Flyers lost Briere for an indeterminate amount of time because the Flyers got a dose of their own medicine.  But the NHL is trying to avoid the perception of the NHL as a renegade sport of blood, fights, and the occassional goal.  Which is why they are trying to do more policing in Toronto and New York Offices and less allowing players to police themselves on the ice.

The Flyers are 7-3 and lead the Atlantic.  They should be the story of this young NHL season.  Instead, because their 3rd and 4th line players can't seem to play within the rules, the league, much to its own chagrin, has been forced to make this story about the 50 games worth of suspensions they have given 3 Flyers players for their eggregious violations of the rules.  We should be talking about Daniel Briere, Simon Gagne and Marty Biron.  Instead, we are left talking about Steve Downie, Jessie Boulerice and Randy Jones.  We should be talking about slick passes, amazing goals and terrific saves.  Instead we are talking about checks to the head, vicious stick assaults and dangerous checks from behind.  Exactly what the NHL does not want, and exactly the reason why Randy Jones will be sitting out the next 2 games.


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
Falcon02520Legend
766 days ago
Score 0+-
dropping like flies...
Permalink | Reply
FrankDDiv-I Stud
766 days ago
Score 0+-
I don't know how I feel about this hit. I think Jones realized one second beforehand that it was a bad idea, but by then it was too late. Not like I'm blaming Patrice for any of it, but if he's going to go near the boards fully knowing someone is behind him then you don't sit on the back of your skates like that, you stand up and take the hit. Moving back like that lowers your center of gravity and as you can see in the hit, puts your head right at board height.
Permalink | Reply
MetsJetsDevilsDraft Pick
766 days ago
Score 0+-
I can't out any of the blame on Bergeron on this one. My big problem with the Jones hit is that it is not like Bergeron turned. I completely understand a players frustration when he is about to hit a guy and the guy spins reulting in a hit from behind. This was a more classic boarding. A guy had his back to the oncoming player/face toward the boards and the player had plenty of time to adjust. This was not a bang bang play. Jones lined the guyup and followed through with the check even though the player clearly had his back to him and had for serveral serveral seconds.

Again, I don't think this makes Jones a dirty player in the same league as Downie or Boulerice. I agree with Homgrem that this type of hit has happened frequently in the NHL and typically results in a penalty, even a 5 minute major, but rarely an injury.

Maybe if other Flyers hadn't tried to kill McAmmond and Kesler, Jones would have gotten the benefit of the doubt. I have to believe that the actions of Downie and Boulerice played into Jones' suspension.
Permalink
Cougar2000All-American
766 days ago
Score 0+-
Sounds to me like the Orange and Black are going back to the old Bobby Clarke/Dave Schultz days. They're getting a bit too chippy and some team in the NHL isn't going to take their shit anymore and haul off on their asses. It would be like Jimmy Stewart shooting Liberty Valance.
Permalink | Reply
Tyrone BriggsHall of Famer
766 days ago
Score 0+-
The Bengals should start scouting the NHL.
Permalink | Reply
CityhockeyfeverVarsity Captain
766 days ago
Score 0+-
Randy Jones should've restrained from the hit from behind in that manner. I agree. It's too bad he had to be suspended, but he has to pay a price for injuring Patrice Bergeron. Even if he apologized and expressed regret for the play, he can't go unpunished in some way because then it sets a precedence that others with less remorse could think they can get away with their actions. I agree, it's too bad the Flyers' good start to the season is being overshadowed by Steve Downie, Jesse Boulerice and now Jones.
Permalink | Reply
Bberg11Varsity
766 days ago
Score 1+-
I can not believe you agree with Burnside's article that the Flyers are encouraging this behavior. That was one of the most ridiculous articles I ever read on ESPN, and that is saying a lot. There is no organizational mandate here that insists these players do these things. Randy Jones' hit was very unitentional, so right there it's not right to use that when arguing that the Flyers are turning into the Broad Street Bullies. Boulerice's attack was inexcusable, and that's why the team immediately cut ties with him. And that only leaves the one hit by Downie. And no matter how you feel about that hit (I happen to feel it was not worthy of a 20 gamer; something but not 20 games), one hit that causes injury is hardly a strong argument for the Flyers being responsible for this type of play.
Permalink | Reply
MetsJetsDevilsDraft Pick
766 days ago
Score 0+-
You have an uphill argument here. The Flyers have the history of the Broad Street Bullies, Paul Holmgrem, one of the toughest, chippiest guys to ever play the game at GM, and have had 50 games worth of suspensions in the first ten games. At some point, people are going to start to wonder. Again, when Boulerice got suspended, they did not fill the spot with a hockey player. Instead they gave his spot to Riley Cote.
Permalink
Steel TownDraft Pick
766 days ago
Score 0+-
Bbearg, you have to take the fan goggles off and look at this objectively. The Flyers play physical hockey, you have to see this. Although they don't play nearly as physical as they did in the 70's it's still that Philly brand of hockey. Even as a Pens fan I enjoy watching the Flyers (but I prefer to watch them lose) finish thier checks and just play tough. I'm with you on the Downie hit. It was illegal but I think the results of that hit are more due to McAmmond not looking where he was going than Downie leaving his feet. And the Jones hit: Jones was wrong but Burgeron does have to be smarter along the boards. Boulerice is garbage and the Flyers sent him packing.
Permalink
Bberg11Varsity
765 days ago
Score 0+-
It has nothing to do with fan goggles, but it does have a lot to do with being around the team all the time. Hockey does not get enough coverage nationally for people outside the Philadelphia area to understand the circumstances behind everything that goes on. Following the team closely, I KNOW that they are not trying to bully teams around. They finished with their worst season ever last year by having players that weren't fast/skilled enough. So all those changes they made this offseason were moving towards a faster/more skilled team, a la the Sabres. I don't see anyone calling the Sabres rise from the basement over the past few years, or the Penguins for that matter, a move toward bully hockey. These three incidents are isolated coincidences; there is no mandate from upper management; and there is no feeling among the players to go out there an hurt people.
Permalink
MetsJetsDevilsDraft Pick
765 days ago
Score 2+-
Cmon. Surely the Flyers have added a lot of talent, but they also put out a team with more thugs than most teams. Eager, Boulerice, Downie, and when Boulerice was released they didn't replace him with a skill player, they replaced him with Riley Cote who has even less skill than the others. I don't disagree that they Flyers have 2 lines of very skillful players, but they also have more thugs than other NHL teams. And they are paying the price for that decision. Also, you have to question the fact that it isn't players of similar skill levels that are being taken out, it is other teams offensively skilled players. It wasn't Chris Neil, Kevin Bieska and Lucic they were knocking out, it was McAmmond, Kesler and Bergeron.
Permalink
Steel TownDraft Pick
765 days ago
Score 1+-
I don't see the Pens and Sabres knocking out the other teams stars. And I am curious how "YOU KNOW" that the Flyers aren't actively trying to bully players.
Permalink
MetsJetsDevilsDraft Pick
765 days ago
Score 0+-
On the lighter said, in college hockey they don't call that penalty "boarding" they call it "checking from behind." Whenever the PA announcer would say "2 minutes checking from behind" us well-eductaed, drunk, Union fans would say in unison "but he likes it from behind."
Permalink | Reply
LASportsblogAAA-er
758 days ago
Score 0+-
Just stop no one likes you Douchebag
Permalink
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free


Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/NHL_Suspends_Yet_Another_Flyer"

This page was last modified 16:43, 30 October 2007. Content is available under the GFDL.

Contribute

ArmchairGM's pages can be edited.
Is this page incomplete? Is there anything wrong?
Change it!

Edit this page Discuss this page Page history

Recent contributors to this page

The following people recently contributed to this article.

Embed this on your site

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise