Fantasy Help --Rate These Players

Here is my team. Jose Reyes, Miguel Tejada, Jason Bay, Miguel Cabrera, Chad Cordero. I have the second pick of this keeper draft. I am deciding between:

Chris Carpenter

<stats> Player=Chris Carpenter Type=Pitching Years=2003,2004,2005 </stats>

Roy Oswalt

<stats> Player=Roy Oswalt Type=Pitching Years=2003,2004,2005 </stats>

Victor Martinez

<stats> Player=Victor Martinez Type=Batting Years=2003,2004,2005 </stats>

Randy Johnson

<stats> Player=Randy Johnson Type=Pitching Years=2003,2004,2005 </stats>

Paul Konerko

<stats> Player=Paul Konerko Type=Batting Years=2003,2004,2005 </stats>

Todd Helton

<stats> Player=Todd Helton Type=Batting Years=2003,2004,2005 </stats>

Adam Dunn

<stats> Player=Adam Dunn Type=Batting Years=2003,2004,2005 </stats>

I am thinking Oswalt, Carpenter, Martinez, your thoughts?

Date

Tue 03/21/06, 7:20 pm EST <pageTools></pageTools>

Enable Comment Auto-Refresher

PeanMajor Leaguer

1332 days ago

Score 1

Definitely Oswalt.

Permalink | Reply

Anonymous Fanatic #1

1331 days ago

Score -1

I would go with Carpenter. More Ks than Oswalt.

Permalink | Reply

Anonymous Fanatic #2

1331 days ago

Score 2

If you want a pitcher go with Carpenter. If you need a batter go with Helton. With that many keepers keep an eye on the positions that are shallow. If you can grab a good 2nd baseman or shortstop, it might be worth more than a guy who you can get similar production to in the next round.

Permalink | Reply

Ap14rcf70

1331 days ago

Score 2

Oswalt a proven commodity. Can Carpenter duplicate? Victor Martinez's upside worth the risk? Good luck man, have a great season!

Permalink | Reply

EnyboDiv-I Stud

1331 days ago

Score 0

Victor Martinez, production like that from your catcher is invaluable, plus pitchers tend to break down more easily. You'll be able to find value later in the draft on pitchers.

Permalink | Reply

Jgov05All-American

1331 days ago

Score 0

Konerko is a 40 homer, 120-RBI treat every year. Go with him.

Permalink | Reply

Bball3345Draft Pick

1331 days ago

Score 3

Actually, Konerko has never had 120 RBIs in a single season in his career but anyways...I would go with Carpenter

Permalink | Reply

JetsrsuperWaterboy

1331 days ago

Score 0

Oswalt, no doubt about it Or as the Canadians say no doobt aboot it

Permalink | Reply

Davis21wylieMVP

1331 days ago

Score 1

Yeah, I bet Carpenter wishes he had some kind of special time machine that could make it perpetually be the year 2005, because that season ain't happening again. Go with Oswalt. Watch out for Helton, he may be leaving Coors this year, and separation anxiety can be big for ex-Rockies (see: Bichette, Dante)... I'd go V. Martinez.

Permalink | Reply