So after a long process of deciding how to decide who the best quarterbacks of all time are, I came up with a list utilizing a scoring system.
I will give you a brief explanation of my formula.
The three basic stats:
1. Yards/Year
2. Touchdowns/Year
3. Interceptions/Year
The yards per year are divided by 100 and then each category is given one point each (Interceptions are given a negative value).
Completion percentage is divided by 10 and given a point.
Next is the accomplishments (ECT) score:
1. Superbowl wins
2. Superbowl losses
3. Championship game losses
4. MVPs
5. All-Pros
Superbowl wins=10pts
Superbowl losses=2.5pts
Championship appearances=1pt
MVPs=7pts
All-Pros=1.5pts
Next Category is winning:
1. Wins
2. Losses
3. Wins/Year
Wins are divided by 10 and given a point
Losses are multiplied by 0.7 and subtracted a point
Wins/Year=1pt
7 years experience minimum.
- Joe Montana
- Peyton Manning
- Otto Graham
- Brett Favre
- Tom Brady
- Johnny Unitas
- John Elway
- Terry Bradshaw
- Dan Marino
- Steve Young
- Troy Aikman
- Kurt Warner
- Bart Starr
- Jim Kelly
- Roger Staubach
- Fran Tarkenton
- Donovan McNabb
- Sid Luckman
- Joe Theismann
- Ken Stabler
- Phil Simms
- Steve McNair
- [[Trent Green
- Bob Griese
- Len Dawson
- Boomer Esiason
- Joe Namath
- Drew Bledsoe
- Rich Gannon
- Ken Anderson
- Dan Fouts
- Jack Kemp
- Warren Moon
- Daryle Lamonica
- Jim Plunkett
- Brad Johnson
- Mark Brunell
- Norm Van Brocklin
- Jeff Garcia
- Roman Gabriel
- Marc Bulger
- Y.A. Tittle
- Neil Lomax
- Matt Hasselbeck
- Jake Delhomme
- Jake Plummer
- Jim Everett
- Kerry Collins
- Drew Brees
- Randall Cunningham