armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan

About the Author

MegECass110
Just taking everything one day at a time.

Follow me on Twitter! twitter.com/MeganCassidy


More By MegECass110

Sunday Smoker - May 24, 2009
12 votes, 5 comments
Ten Things Michael Vick Can Do To Make Me Kinda Like Him
15 votes, 17 comments
Sunday Smoker - May 17
15 votes, 19 comments
View All

Other recent voters

If you like the article, vote for it.
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

The Evolution of a Fanhood, Part Deux: MegECass110 and Manchester United

by MegECass110
created May 22, 2008, last edited February 10, 2009
20
Vote

Image:44678330 ronaldo4 getty416.jpg

Photo courtesy of Getty Images, BBC


I know what this looks like. I know what some of you may be thinking...What?!?! She's a Chelsea fan! She's a bandwagoner! She's rubbish!' You are all perfectly entitled to thinking this. I would probably think the same thing if I was in your shoes.

In a sense, I view being a sports fan as a progression. There are definitely some cases where you attach yourself to a team, and they perform in such a profoundly awesome way, win or lose, that you live and die with them. This is often the case with geographical proximity (for me, BC, the Sox, Pats and Syracuse).

But there are other times when you already have a team, and you fall in love with another. People change, teams do too. I don't believe in the one-and-only concept, where a fan is limited to one team per sport. You can primarily root for one, but enjoy watching another. Some inconceivably great game occurs between two teams you care nothing about, and you are riveted by them. This is kind of what happened to me this afternoon during the UEFA Champions League Final, between Chelsea and Manchester United.

I came to London determined to not be a ManU fan. From what I heard, they were basically the Yankees of the Premier League. Some of my friends were already ManU fans, and I wanted to have something unique. That came in the form of Chelsea, a chic West London powerhouse, and Fulham, a lovable loser on the banks of the Thames. Opposites attract, I guess.

ManU and Chelsea performed very well over the course of the Premier League season. It wasn't the performance that changed my views of Chelsea and ManU, it was their history. A book I read, How Soccer Explains the World, had a revealing chapter about Chelsea's hooliganism and history of anti-Semitism. Although my professor revealed to me that the primary source for this chapter may have been full of shite, it still turned me off. In the same class, we watched a film on three famed football managers, Jock Stein, Bill Shankly, and ManU's Matt Busby. Busby is known for rebuilding ManU after a 1958 plane crash killed eight players and some team personnel. Ten years later, United became the first team to win the European Cup. The heroic aspect of it all made me rethink my choice of Premier League team.

Can a beautiful football shirt change the way you think about a team? Absolutely.
Can a beautiful football shirt change the way you think about a team? Absolutely.

Chelsea and ManU went down to the wire in the race for the Premier League title, highlighted by a thrilling 2-1 win for Chelsea at Stamford Bridge on my final days in London (only surpassed by Fulham's inexplicably exhilarating escape from relegation with a 2-0 win over Birmingham). ManU edged out the Blues for the league title, and both teams continued to advance in the UEFA Champions League tournament, but in different ways. Chelsea did it with the help from a Liverpool own goal that forced a draw in the semis. As opposed to ManU, which did it with the help two particularly spectacular goals, one a magnificent soaring header by Cristiano Ronaldo against Roma and another a flat-out rocket off the foot of Paul Scholes in the semi-finals against Barcelona (another team I became fascinated by at the hands of the aforementioned book). Another thing...in the Roma match, ManU wore white jerseys that I absolutely loved. They were so simple, but so intimidating. I returned stateside excited for their matchup in the final.

Which brings us to this afternoon. My mom repeatedly asked me who I was rooting for, and I continued to tell her I liked both teams, that I was neutral. But as the game went on, I realized I was anything but. I can't really explain it, but I wanted ManU to win. I just did. I tried to convince myself otherwise, to root for Chelsea, but I couldn't. It was impossible.

Maybe it's because Edwin Van Der Sar is perhaps the greatest name meant to be given to a pirate, but given to a goalie instead.

Maybe it's because Cristiano Ronaldo scored ManU's only goal in regulation, then missed his penalty shot, then proceeded to convulsively sob at the center of the pitch after Van Der Sar saved Nicolas Anelka's shot to clinch the win. I hope he wasn't acting. If he was, I was still undeniably turned on. All I wanted to do was grab one of those white fluffy towels, fly to Moscow, dry the rain and tears off his face, and give him a hug. Moving on...

Maybe it's because Didier Drogba gave Nemanja Vidic the wimpiest bitch slap in world history, and got a red card when he knew his team would need him for penalty shots.

Maybe it's because I didn't like Chelsea's new shirts.

Maybe it's because both teams missed so many opportunities, I became frustrated to the point where I wanted ManU to win because they got closer each time.

Maybe it's because Frank Lampard wasn't nearly as attractive as I thought he was.

Maybe it's because I kept thinking Petr Cech was a member of security and not the goalie in his neon orange kit.

In the end, I knew I didn't feel the same about Chelsea as I used to when John Terry fell to his knees. Normally, I would feel sorry for the Chelsea captain, who had the chance to win the game on his penalty shot, but slipped on the turf and missed.

But I didn't feel any sympathy. I could only be happy for ManU. I was mesmerized by the efficiency and resiliency of the Red Devils, and the exuberance with which they played the game. I had seen it all season, but denied myself appreciating it because a) I already had my teams, b) I didn't want to root for the football version of the Yankees, and c) I didn't want my liking of the team to be solely based on Ronaldo. I like them all. I really do. I just didn't realize it.

I can't decide if I like Chelsea anymore. Would I feel the same way if Chelsea had won, if Terry's shot had gone in? I think so. I fell in and out with a team in the span of four months. I think I fell in love with London and Chelsea's ambiance and novelty more than the team itself. I've never been in this position of indecisive fandom. It's an awkward feeling, but it's overshadowed by a new love.

I am a Red. Deal with it.


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
Anonymous Fanatic #1
559 days ago
Score 2+-
I got home in time to watch the shootout and I'm watching the replay now!!! I've been a MAN U fan my entire life, and a very happy MAN U fan today. Thrilling finish in a great match, could not ask for more!
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #1
559 days ago
Score 1+-
That was me!
Permalink | Reply
DRE-LOAAA-er
559 days ago
Score 3+-
NO, THIS IS ME! AND SO WAS THAT! {Double brainfart}
Permalink | Reply
Cougar2000All-American
559 days ago
Score 1+-
Meg a bandwaggoner? NAH! She's too smart and good looking to be a bandwaggoner.
Permalink | Reply
LASportsblogAAA-er
559 days ago
Score 2+-
I'm going to withhold comment because I like Meg. But I don't endorse this at all. You wait til AFTER they beat Chelsea in the CL Final to jump ship? That's not very cool in any context.
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
559 days ago
Score 0+-
First off, congratulations to Manchester United for winning. It was a pretty exciting game, to say the least, from what it sounds like. Secondly, I have no problems with the fact that you like both teams, Meg. Regardless of who you decide to become a fan of is up to you. I will respect that decision and still appreciate talking to a loyal fan of the game of soccer.
Permalink | Reply
RohandevganAll-American
559 days ago
Score 0+-
I have been a United fan for 13 years now and have been watching trends develop. Chelsea never had fan support it was only after the money and players came in. However even with United I have seen a lot of 'fake' fans who have only turned loyalties after this season. none of them stood by when United were building in the last 3 years. who can forget the 2004-05-06 seasons in the C.League when United failed to even get past the group stages. Today i really dont care coz i will always stand by even if others dont.
Permalink | Reply
Pittsburgh GunnyMajor Leaguer
559 days ago
Score 0+-
Me, I can't stand either team but congrats to United as I can bear them winning it as opposed to that blue rabble from the west side of London.
Permalink | Reply
JuTMSY4Legend
559 days ago
Score 1+-
I don't believe in the one-and-only concept, where a fan is limited to one team per sport. You can primarily root for one, but enjoy watching another

I suppose...I think i've made my thoughts clear on bandwagon jumping. That being said, I sorta agree Meg (and sorta not)...

For example, who didn't enjoy watching Colorado play last year (MLB)? Scrappy team, fun to watch, had a lot of heart...but i wouldn't go out and buy a rockies hat...

I guess that's the determining factor...this happens a lot to me in football...i like to see bad teams progress to good...but only for a little (then i get bored with them). But I'm not a fan of those teams
Permalink | Reply
MegECass110AAA-er
559 days ago
Score 0+-
There is a difference, you're right. That's how it started for me and ManU, I just enjoyed watching them. But over the course of the season, other factors came into play, and it went to the next level.
Permalink
A QQVarsity
558 days ago
Score 0+-
Quote"Other factors came into play, and it went to the next level."

First i believe it was C.Ronldo...duuh!

Second, the Exciting way Man United Plays there game, its mezmorizing the way they pass, score and Shot on Goal...
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
558 days ago
Score 0+-
Now, I agree with you, JuT. That's a pretty good way to put it: I enjoy seeing bad teams (or teams who are/were considered bad, I should say) do well over the course of the season. I started to gain interest in Tampa Bay before the season started, and now that they're in second place, I am happy for them. I also like the fact that the Giants are in 3rd right now. Same goes for the Astros. (Go Berkman!) It's just something natural for a sports fan to like: seeing mediocre teams doing really well.
Permalink
RohandevganAll-American
559 days ago
Score 0+-
there's a difference between rooting for one team and enjoying watching other teams. i havent missed a single premier league match this season but im a die hard united fan and always will be. i sure enjoyed watching other games but i will be a united fan for life. its actually a lot of fun watching other teams playing hard when you're relaxed because your team is not playing. Less stress
Permalink | Reply
InterMatAll-American
559 days ago
Score 0+-
So if you're a fan, for what, two weeks before really getting a taste of something you like, you're "stuck."

I think if there is a rooting interest that waffles from year to year, yeah, no way you're getting by with that, but I wasn't a tremendous Tool fan until I saw them live. Am I a bandwagon fan for totally digging a band after seeing them in person. I think the same concept applies for sports, especially if you're in foreign territory (meaning sports you're not accustomed).

I'm desperately searching for some Premier League teams to root for. I watch Setanta all the time and have been following the game, but without a local attraction, a local flavor, I can't just "pick." I think Meg had the same similar issue. Picking one, then seeing the entire field of view.

Growing up a Bucs fan, I stick with my teams, but I can't tell you "who" my favorite Premier League team is, except in the Scottish Premier, where it's Celtic (due to heritage, not a scoreboard).
Permalink | Reply
CityhockeyfeverVarsity Captain
559 days ago
Score 2+-
Another yet outstanding article, Megan. While I didn't have a chance at the time to comment on your previous soccer article "How the Premiership Stole My Heart", I have to say that you have a great true love for the sport and it's great to hear you talk about it in your own words. What I mean is that you describe it so well and with passion behind it.

I didn't watch this match at the time it was played, but I must tell you that definitely had an interest in seeing all the highlights. How that shootout unfolded was remarkable. When a player shooting a penalty kick falls on his rear end and misses wide with the goaltender going the opposite direction, boy that has got to be the second worst feeling in the game (behind putting the ball into your own goal).

As far your split loyalties, who can blame you. It's really tough when you enjoy rooting for two teams like that such as Chelsea and Manchester United. The thing is, isn't it almost like the Yankees and Red Sox? Obviously it's shameful to root for both New York AND Boston. But here, I understand where you come from with these two high profile soccer franchises. I grew up in a family that has Mets fans AND Yankees fans, so I didn't really gravitate to just one New York baseball team and have no love (or hatred) for the other. But I don't abandon one when they suck either like some fans might. In hockey, I have my hometown New York Rangers and then have the Minnesota Wild and Phoenix Coyotes split right down the middle in terms of how I feel about those two teams and how dedicated I am as a fan. It's not uncommon, but I do kind of draw the line when we're talking about bitter archenemies like the Red Sox and Yankees or the Rangers and Islanders.

Lastly, my friend Dan who is beat reporter for the Champions Soccer Radio Network is someone I know who is a huge (and I mean HUGE) soccer fan and I know he paid plenty of attention to this match. He cannot wait for the World Cup tournament to be played this summer.

Thanks again for providing your perspective on this match and everything you described in regards to the history of these two sports franchises. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
558 days ago
Score 0+-
Great comment, Cityhockeyfever. Couldn't have said it better. I would just like to contradict you on one little thing: I wouldn't consider Liverpool and Chelsea to be anything like the Red Sox and Yankees... yet. The only similarity between the two feuds is that are all four teams are "currently" considered to be really good teams. Chelsea doesn't have that much of a winning (or should I say championship) history. It's not about rooting for teams who are in a rivalry: it's about rooting for two teams that are currently good. If I was in my first year of becoming a soccer fan, like you said, I wouldn't blame Meg for liking both Chelsea and Man U right now. It's probably for that same reason that I like Real Madrid right now. It's up to you what team you "root for", or who you cheer for.
Permalink
OvertheedgeVarsity
558 days ago
Score 0+-
i was waiting for the chelsea goalie to streak across the field, good game though
Permalink | Reply
SalmanpourVarsity
558 days ago
Score 0+-
First of all, the pic you have of Christiano Ronaldo he looks like he's doing ballet. Manchester United deserve the win after crushing every team they faced. However, I still think that Chelsea shouldn't have played in the Semi-finals, it should have been Liverpool.
Permalink | Reply
SalmanpourVarsity
558 days ago
Score 0+-
Finals Not semi-fianls
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
558 days ago
Score 0+-
Liverpool may have been a better team, whether it was talent wise, team chemistry wise, whatever. However, that's how the chips fall sometimes. Chelsea played very well to make it to the finals, and played a very hard fought game agaainst Man U, keeping the game tied at 1. Either way, Liverpool, Chelsea, Tottenham... if you make the finals, you earn it.
Permalink
SalmanpourVarsity
558 days ago
Score 0+-
Not all teams that make it to the FINALS earns it. If you have heard about Juventus scheme with paying the referee to reef gods knows how many games, and they won many times. Is that a team that earns it?
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
558 days ago
Score -1+-
So you're using the refs as an excuse against Juventus for winning the game? Every single game? There are bad calls made in every game. They can be in favor of one team or the other. If the refs deliberately make bad calls in every single game that Juventus played, then yes... I wouldn't say they earned. But it would've caused a HUGE (and I mean "the whole world knows" HUGE) debate and controversy for that entire season.
Permalink
SalmanpourVarsity
558 days ago
Score 1+-
I didn't use it as an EXCUSE for them to win, if you didn't know the Juventus was punished for it, got sent to Division 2, lost a lot of talented players, and lost respect of lots of fans. Chelsea is a good team, but they need to fix some of their formations and they will become a good team. They need to get young players and not get the best players in the world.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
558 days ago
Score 1+-
Sorry, I didn't see the key word in your comment there, buddy: PAY. (I didn't know they paid the refs) Please accept my apology, as I only got a 430/800 in the Reading Comp part of my SATs. ;P
Permalink
SalmanpourVarsity
558 days ago
Score 1+-
hahaha, its okay. Everybody does Mistakes.... Gorge Bush gets confused which is his right hand and left hand ;p
Permalink
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free
Categories: Opinions | Opinions by User MegECass110 | May 22, 2008 | May 2008 | Soccer Opinions

Don't Miss

Phillies World Series 2009: A Year Later, and They Still Don't Want Us
Sorry, But I'm Not Sorry
2009 NHL Preview
In Which Ricketts Wins World Series
2009 Week 3: Let’s Talk About Your Favorite NFL Team

In the News

Hey ArmchairGM users! Want to help the admins update this news section? Click here to help us out.

Comments of the Day

0 ^6^
0 boat racing!!!
0 Flora edit it
0 Wowww O_O thai sport !!!
0 Cool !!! page

Play the Quiz Game

in 1983 Dave Winfield hit & killed a seagull with a thrown baseball. In what city did this occur?

New Articles

Thai Circle Takraw
JACK-STONES (MARK-KEB)
Boat racing (Kaeng Ruer)
Kraabi Krabong! thai sport
Week 13: Bobby Bowden's Last Play

Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Article:The_Evolution_of_a_Fanhood%2C_Part_Deux:_MegECass110_and_Manchester_United"

This page was last modified 01:37, 22 May 2008. Content is available under the GFDL.

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise