armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan

About the Author

Barkingclam
Freelance writer, student

More By Barkingclam

Barkingclam's Super Bowl Notebook
12 votes, 5 comments
John Updike - The Original Free Darko
5 votes, 0 comments
CBC documentary on Habs leaves much to be desired
6 votes, 3 comments
View All

Other recent contributors

Make this page better by editing it.

Other recent voters

If you like the article, vote for it.
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

On the cusp of a better world of sport

by Barkingclam
created May 17, 2008, last edited June 03, 2008
15
Vote

We’re sitting on the cusp of something very big here.

No, not Hideki Matsui’s porn collection. I’m talking about a new, more equal frontier of athletics.

Yesterday, The Court of Arbitration for Sport ruled that amputee sprinter Oscar Pistorius can race in the Olympics, overturning an earlier ruling that said his prosthetic legs gave him an unfair advantage.

This latest, and perhaps most important, development shows a trend that sports is fast becoming more and more equal, just as society is.

We now live in an age where gay marriage is legal in California; where both a black man and a woman have a shot at being elected as President; where everybody has a chance to compete.

A little over a month ago, Danica Patrick won her first race (the Indy Japan 300), marking the first time that race has been won by a woman – and meaning that Patrick means business.

No longer a curiosity or an also-ran, Patrick is even being considered a favorite now for the Indy 500. Patrick, the driver whose small frame was considered an unfair advantage, could win one of the most famous races in the world.

Funny thing, those unfair advantages. Where else in the world would your gender, or the amount of leg you have, be considered not just unfair, but also an advantage.

When Patrick first started to race, some suggested that she races with weighed plates – making her car heavier then anybody else’s – to make the races fairer. After her win, one newspaper asked “is it time to start taking her seriously as a driver?”

Never mind that she had been racing in the IRL since 2005 and was named rookie of the year, right? She was just a curiosity on four wheels.

It’s not a lot different for Pistorius, either. Like Patrick, it’s easy to see him as a novelty, the racer who runs on fiberglass blades. But there’s something else, too. Like Patrick, he also has an overlooked advantage.

Determination. Patrick did not give up racing, even though she did not win a race in her first two seasons. She refused to let herself be put in the same class as other curiosities as Manon Rheaume or Amy Williams.

Pistorius did not give up when the Internation Association of Athletics Federations ruled he could not race. He fought that decision, right up to the highest court in sport, where he won his appeal.

It’s hard to see many of today’s more successful athletes to have the same kind of determination. If a basketball player doesn’t like his college coach, he can transfer to another school. If a hockey player doesn’t like his team, he can force a trade.

If they feel they’ve been slighted, they can just complain about it to the media or on their blog.

Instead, both Patrick and Pistorius both hung in and each ended up winning the respect they should have had all along.

And sport is better for it.


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
DRE-LOAAA-er
413 days ago
Score 1+-
This is a great moment for sports!
Permalink | Reply
MegECass110AAA-er
413 days ago
Score 3+-
The Pistorious story is sooooooooo interesting...talk about seeing both sides of an issue. My personal opinion is, if you have overcome the physical and mental obstacles of having part of your legs amputated to even be CONSIDERED on the same level with able-bodied athletes, you've earned the right to race with them.
Permalink | Reply
Alex HolowczakHall of Famer
413 days ago
Score 5+-
I hate the idea that Pistorius can run at the Olympics (should he qualify). There can be no debate as to whether his legs give him an advantage. They are not his legs! It's clearly an artificial aid, something the IOC will naturally ban. Under the "artificial aid" rule, he is clearly infringing the rules of competition. If he can run without his legs, then fine, go ahead. Look at Natalie du Toit, a South African swimmer. She competes in able bodied swimming events without a prosthetic limb. That's absolutely fine. I understand that it wasn't Pistorius' fault etc. but it can never be claimed not to be an unfair advantage. Comparing it to Danica Patrick is confusing, because Patrick didn't break any rules to take part. No rule says that women can't race. Athletics (Track & Field) rules state you can't use artificial aids to help (such as steroids). Pistorius is surely breaking the rules.
Permalink | Reply
Manny StilesMajor Leaguer
413 days ago
Score 1+-
I hear what you're saying - Personally, I don't think Danica compares to Pistorius at all - and I can't say I disagree with your opinion, but scientific studies have shown that the advantage the blades have over a normal human leg is a 92% return of energy with the prosthesics vs. a 89% normal leg. That's fairly incremental, especially when you consider that he gets a VERY slow jump at the line (certainly much more than a 3% difference)

It definitely raises competitive fairness issues but I think if you take all things into consideration, he is still at a disadvantage over able bodied runners...


And he can bring a wonderful human element angle to the Olympics.


Afterall Alex, the motto and creed for the Olympics is:

"The most important thing in the Olympic Games is not to win but to take part, just as the most important thing in life is not the triumph but the struggle. The essential thing is not to have conquered but to have fought well."

I think he doesn't just fit that spirit, he defines it.


Besides, he isn't going to win anyway...
Permalink
Manny StilesMajor Leaguer
413 days ago
Score 1+-
And when we start drawing lines at what is "artificial aid" and what is "natural", you get the imminent slippery slope. Access to superior training aids, reconstructive surgeries, contact lenses, drinking gatorade instead of water... etc.
Permalink
BarkingclamVarsity
413 days ago
Score 2+-
What I was trying to say is that both athletes shouldn't be defined - or denied - by what makes them different. Don't forget, people were really against Patrick when she started in the IRL; that she was a gimmick, that she was too light (and hereby faster), that it was another attack on a 'boys club'.

I don't see much of a difference for Pistorius. He shouldn't be defined as "that bladed runner" anymore then Patrick as "that lighter driver" or Tiger Woods as "that LASIKed golfer".

Sure, his legs give him an advantage. But the runners who train in a hyperbolic chamber have an advantage, too, and nobody is saying they shouldn't complete.
Permalink
Taytay 24All-American
412 days ago
Score 1+-
To add to Manny's list of "artificial aids": what about shoes?
Permalink
Steel TownDraft Pick
411 days ago
Score 1+-
Wow, only three percent. That is surprising. But, I suspect, that can be the differnce between first and second place. I understand why a lot of people are happy about this. It is a nice story. But, I find it hard to believe that even an incremental advantage can be accepted.


"what about shoes?" I think there is a big leap from fiberglass blades (springs) to shoes.

Imagine what would happen if an able bodied person found a way to use the blades. It is an unfortunate situatino for Pistorious, but I just can't agree with the ruling.
Permalink
Taytay 24All-American
411 days ago
Score 0+-
I'm not making a leap from blades to shoes. Manny pointed out that "artificial aids" is a slippery slope and gave a few examples. I simply added another fundamental "artificial aid" that every runner uses. Unless you are arguing that shoes are natural...
Permalink
OvertheedgeVarsity
412 days ago
Score 0+-
pistorious should not be allowed to run, that is what the special olympics are for
Permalink | Reply
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free
Categories: Opinions | Opinions by User Barkingclam | May 17, 2008 | May 2008 | Sports Opinions | Olympics Opinions | IRL Opinions | Danica Patrick Opinions | Oscar Pistorius Opinions | Auto Racing Opinions | Racing Opinions | General Opinions

Don't Miss

Chris Davis' Obscene Strikeout Pace
What Else is New?
Goose Gossage is Right: Closers and Relief Pitchers Cannot Be Compared
SSR Interviews: USMNT Soccer Talk With Joshua Mayers
What America's Loss to Brazil Might Mean

In the News

The United States Senate plans to hold a hearing next week to investigate antitrust issues surrounding the Bowl Championship Series.

Comments of the Day

0 this is cool
0 Ummm...do you mean football figures? I"m confused here...
0 There are lots of WoW gamers are looking around for ...
0 hello dear my name is marry and my contact address is(marryja...

Play the Quiz Game

Two teams in the NHL have only two colors. Who are they ?

New Articles

Coke Zero 400 at Daytona Betting Odds Picks
The potential first NASCAR Hall of Fame class
My Top 201 football players
Wimbledon Men’s Semifinal Betting – Tennis Betting Online
Picks and Parlay Radio Show Two Team Parlay for 7/3/9

Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Article:On_the_cusp_of_a_better_world_of_sport"

This page was last modified 21:34, 17 May 2008. Content is available under the GFDL.

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise