armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan

About the Author

FrankD
http://www.pensburgh.com

More By FrankD

Interview with Jack Falla, author of "Saved"
14 votes, 4 comments
Wings Take the Cup, Beat Pitt 3-2
16 votes, 14 comments
Penguins Force Game Six, Win in Third OT
16 votes, 23 comments
View All

Other recent contributors

Make this page better by editing it.

Other recent voters

If you like the article, vote for it.
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

NHL All-Star Game - Way to Save the Game?

by FrankD
created January 27, 2008, last edited February 10, 2009
12
Vote

More at http://www.pensburgh.com

08_ASG_logo_411.jpg

Time for the much anticipated, highly overrated and non-violent hockey game known as the All-Star Game. Stars from all around the league convene in one location to daintily bump, effortlessly save and casually score amidst a sea of pseudo-fans. This year, the locale of choice: Atlanta, Georgia.

Nice move by the NHL to attract fans to one of the league's smallest markets for hockey. In the autobiography titled "The Kid" (about Crosby), Sid mentions how playing in Atlanta compared to Montreal/Toronto was always a pleasant break. In Montreal he'd get mobbed from the second he stepped out the side door to head off to the bus. In Atlanta, he could eat at a street-side restaurant and not be noticed by a single person.

Too bad he won't be on camera tomorrow. Looks like Atlanta still needs a lesson in a robust game of "Who is Sidney Crosby?"

Now I've mentioned before that I've never been one to really care much about the All-Star Game. And in fact, this post so far has taken a very biased approach to the game and so I'll apologize now for doing so. Feel free to ostracize me in the comments section.

However, it does seem like a league-wide, seemingly acceptable thought to accept the All-Star Game as a lost cause. Which is why I was so interested in THN's (The Hockey News) article in their January 22 issue titled "56 Ways to Save The All-Star Game." 56 reasons, of course, because this is the 56th All-Star Game.

It's more or less a tongue in cheek list, but some of the ideas aren't too far fetched.

Here are a few from the list. Each is quoted directly from the THN issue.

01 Change the format. How about introducing Age Rage, with the enthusiastic under-30 guys going up against the crotchety over-30 crowd.

03 Or left-handed shot all-stars versus right-handed shot all-stars

07 Mic up every player and broadcast the best clips during breaks in the action. To take it a step further, have stretches while the game is being played - where the only audio is on-ice chatter.

08 Have all the players stay in the same hotel. On the same floor. With a 24-hour reality TV crew on hand.

12 Invite top junior and college players to the skills competition (John Tavares vs. Marty Turco in a shootout drill, followed by Alex Ovechkin vs Simeon Varlamov).

13 New skills competition: Bodychecking. Imaging Dion Phaneuf vs Shane Weber in the final, skating full force into a tackling dummy - whoever makes it fly the furthest, win. Seriously...fans would go nuts.

22 Assign each period a point value. For example, winning the first period is worth one point, the second two points and the third three points. That keeps the game interesting should the score be lopsided entering the third.

25 Have a celebrity of hockey legend do the PA announcing on goal calls.

28 Play the game on international ice. Give those all-stars room to move.

29 The winning conference gets home-ice advantage in the Stanley Cup final.

34 Every penalty, anywhere on the ice, results in a penalty shot.

39 No icing the puck on penalty kills.

41 Play the game in Europe or a non-NHL North American city.

47 Play it outdoors

48 Play it after the season's over

49 Play it in the pre-season. Fans are hungry for hockey after three long summer months...and anything that spices up the exhibition schedule is welcome.

51 Bring back the goalie helmet cam.

56 Ah, what the heck, let's see what happens if they throw two pucks on the ice instead of the usual boring, old one. Or, maybe one puck in the first, two in the seconds and three in the third. Could make for some cool hat tricks.
THN - January 22, 2008 Issue

I skipped over certain numbers only because certain ones were NUMBER - Bigger nets. NUMBER - Smaller nets. You get the point...

On a personal note, I agree with 22 (point values for periods), 29 (winning conference gets home ice in finals), 49 (play it during pre-season) and 51 (goalie cams).

What say you?

PS - I just pray I don't read that Malkin and Gonchar collided and will both be out 4-6 weeks with high-ankle sprains, concussions and broken fibulas.


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
Cougar2000All-American
654 days ago
Score 1+-
First off, it was Atlanta's turn but the strike took care of that, so Atlanta had to wait. Secondly, I doubt if any of the ideas would work, with the exception of numbers 25 and 51. 29 would not work... remember the MLB All-Star game with the winning league getting the advantage in the World Series?
Permalink | Reply
RawbeezeitzMajor Leaguer
653 days ago
Score 0+-
but that wasn't disastrous that the winning league wins home field advantage. It could add a bit more importance to the game, especially with 20 or so teams still in contention at the break.
Permalink
FrankDDiv-I Stud
653 days ago
Score 1+-
I thought it was a pretty ridiculous list myself. Some of them would be mildly feasible, but at the same time completely stupid. You should've seen the ones I didn't even bother putting in here.

As for home-ice, I don't see why it wouldn't work. I really wish i could find the article I read stating that out all of the sports, hockey is the least affected by home-ice advantage.

You could of course wind up having a series like Carolina vs Edmonton again, where Edmonton just barely clawed into the playoffs and then made it to the finals. If the West won that all-star game, the number 8 seed would've had home ice advantage. Not that it would hurt NHL revenue to have more potential games in a Canadian venue...
Permalink
The PipDiv-I Stud
653 days ago
Score 0+-
The NFL, NBA, and NHL should get together and package their all-star events during the same weekend in the same city. The honor of being an all-star is punished by forcing them to play in a game no one cares about. Now in theory a game between the best players in the game that season is a great idea, but for many reasons it fails. So make it fun. Have the 3 sports put up their best in a decathlon (Not a american gladiators, but some real athletic contest), or a cross sport skills tourney (3 point shoutout NFL vs NHL or a skating contest between the NFL and NBA, or flag football game between the NBA and NHL), or something, anything actually interesting (scrabble!) to get fans interested. Or heck just play the three games on the same weekend in the same city, the star power alone will make it worthwhile.
Permalink | Reply
FrankDDiv-I Stud
652 days ago
Score 0+-
I think you're onto something. You'd have to make sure you do it well enough so though it doesn't look anything like Pros vs Joes. All credibility would be lost in that case...
Permalink
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free
Categories: Opinions | Opinions by User FrankD | January 27, 2008 | January 2008 | NHL Opinions | Pittsburgh Penguins Opinions | Washington Capitals Opinions | Philadelphia Flyers Opinions | New York Rangers Opinions

Don't Miss

Phillies World Series 2009: A Year Later, and They Still Don't Want Us
Sorry, But I'm Not Sorry
2009 NHL Preview
In Which Ricketts Wins World Series
2009 Week 3: Let’s Talk About Your Favorite NFL Team

In the News

The battle between Adidas and the University of Central Florida over the brand of shoes Michael Jordan's son will wear has cost the school any future sponsorship with Adidas. Ring, ring. That must be Nike on the phone.

Comments of the Day

0 why join in sports
0 Because snooker is a sport... And sports are facking AWESOM...
0 i personally think this list has no validity. it does...
0 I don"t think money is the object here. Even if he...

Take a Poll

Did Babe Ruth ever get sick on hotdogs during a Yankees Game?
Yes No

New Articles

From Ninth to First: What If the Red Sox Had Tony Conigliaro in October?
Baseball & Basketball losing it!
Whether James will leave the Cleveland Cavaliers or not?
Bad Flashbacks: An Analysis of USC v ASU
What If Brad Lidge Had Started Game One?

Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Article:NHL_All-Star_Game_-_Way_to_Save_the_Game%3F"

This page was last modified 16:41, 27 January 2008. Content is available under the GFDL.

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise