It's Finally Official, Renteria Signs

Although the initial report came about 2 weeks premature, the inevitable did finally happen officially on Thursday afternoon as the Giants signed shortstop Edgar Renteria to a 2 year, $18.5 million contract. I've gone over Renteria in depth over the past couple posts so I can't say much that hasn't already been said. I don't love this deal by any stretch, but I don't hate it either. Again, I would have rather seen Rafael Furcal sign since they were insisting on adding a shortstop, as I think his ceiling is extremely higher at this point that Renteria's (Yes, even with the back concerns). That said, I fully expect Edgar to be closer to his offensive career averages next season after a sub-par year in Detroit. Renteria, by far, is better offensively than anyone the Giants have had at shortstop since earlier in the decade when a younger Rich Aurilia was playing all-star quality baseball for this team. The good news about Renteria is that he's supposedly working out diligently in order to right himself after last years disappointment, so he seems determined to rebound. Remember, he is just 2 years removed from an all-star season in Atlanta (.332, 12 home runs, 57 RBI, 11 SB in 124 games). At 33, he doesn't have any breakout type seasons left in him, but I do expect an average around .290-.300, with 10-15 home runs and 60-70 RBI at the top of the Giants order while being a steady hand in the middle of the infield. I see him as the shortstop equivalent to Randy Winn, without as much speed. Again, not a game changer, but should be fine over the next 2 seasons and an upgrade to what they previously had.

The Giants have been the most active team in baseball this winter and they aren't done yet. In addition to looking for more offense at the infield corners, they also have their eye on this years big fish. It appears C.C. Sabathia is very much on their radar and the consensus around the league is that Sabathia's two most likely destinations are San Francisco and New York (Yankees). If the Giants did land C.C., they would likely trade Matt Cain for a power hitter, so you need to take that into account when assessing this situation. Still unlikely, but this story is starting to play out very similar to the Barry Zito two winters ago. More on this to come!

Article from The Giants Baseball Blog http://giantsbaseballblog.blogspot.com/

Tmil42AAA-er

340 days ago

Score 0

I don't think they would have gotten Furcal for 2 years, but rather for something in the range of 3-4 years. And I'd rather have Renteria for 2 years than Furcal for 4 years.

Permalink | Reply

Trecole696Red-Shirting

340 days ago

Score 0

They absolutely wouldn't have gotten Furcal for 2 years. But that's my point, you don't build a ballclub around guys that come cheaply, you try and build around talent. They clearly would have preferred Furcal as Sabean pursued him first, but settled for Renteria. That's my beef. And Furcal is looking for 3-4 years but is also 2 years younger than Renteria. I don't hate this move, just saying there was a better player out there, and they have the money.

Permalink | Reply