ArmchairGM MLB Hall of Fame voting results!
| 7
|
by user Demonboy
| AGM MLB Hall of Fame Poll: | Cs | 1Bs | 2Bs | SSs | 3Bs | LFs | CFs | RFs | DHs | SPs | RPs | Managers | Pioneers |
After over a month of voting, the ArmchairGM MLB Hall of Fame poll has finally closed. The rules were as follows:
"When all voting is complete, points will be added to see where the players rank overall against other players of the same . A first place vote is worth 10 points, a second place vote worth 9, third place worth 8, and so on.
All players or coaches with a score equal to the number of participants * 3 or higher will be inducted into the ArmchairGM Hall of Fame."
Here is the list of players that are now members of the ArmchairGM Hall of Fame!
Players in bold next to their name were unanimously inducted as the #1 player at their position.
Catchers (min points required - 51)
- Johnny Bench (65)
- Yogi Berra (55)
Notables that did not make it - Carlton Fisk (48), Roy Campanella (45), Gary Carter (36) & Gabby Hartnett (18)
First Basemen (min points required - 66)
No player had enough points to make the Hall of Fame.
Notables that did not make it - Jimmie Foxx (50), Lou Gehrig (50), Stan Musial (35), Eddie Murray (33), Don Mattingly (12)
Second Basemen (min points required - 51)
- Rogers Hornsby (53)
Notables that did not make it - Jackie Robinson (45), Joe Morgan (30), Ryne Sandberg (19)
ShortStops (min points required - 63)
No player had enough points to make the Hall of Fame.
Notables that did not make it - Honus Wagner (52), Ernie Banks (47), Robin Yount (33), Ozzie Smith (29), Cal Ripken (28)
Third Basemen (min points required - 57)
- Mike Schmidt (57)
Notables that did not make it - George Brett (51), Wade Boggs (42), Brooks Robinson (36)
Left Fielders (min points required - 57)
No player had enough points to make the Hall of Fame.
Notables that did not make it - Ted Williams (50), Carl Yastrzemski (22), Lou Brock (19)
Center Fielders (min points required - 42)
- Willie Mays (43)
Notables that did not make it - Joe DiMaggio (41), Mickey Mantle (39), Ty Cobb (37), Kirby Puckett (19)
Right Fielders (min points required - 39)
- Babe Ruth (40)
Notables that did not make it - Hank Aaron (35), Frank Robinson (29), Roberto Clemente (22)
Designated Hitters
There were only 2 people who voted in this category so no DH got inducted.
Notables - Paul Molitor (20), Edgar Martinez (17)
Starting Pitchers (min points required - 63)
No player had enough points to make the Hall of Fame.
Notables that did not make it - Walter Johnson (49), Cy Young (37), Nolan Ryan (26), Sandy Koufax (25)
Relief Pitchers (min points required - 48)
No player had enough points to make the Hall of Fame.
Notables that did not make it - Lee Smith (44), Dennis Eckersley (42), Rollie Fingers (32), Bruce Sutter (31)
Managers (min points required - 36)
No manager had enough points to make the Hall of Fame.
Notables that did not make it - Casey Stengel (35), Sparky Anderson (30), Earl Weaver (22), Tommy Lasorda (17), Billy Martin (5)
Pioneers of Baseball
There were only 2 people who voted in this category so no pioneer got inducted.
Notables - Abner Doubleday (20), Bill Veeck (15)
Date
Mon 09/11/06, 4:47 am EST
