ACGM NFL ROOKIE OF THE YEAR

Ill throw a vote in for Ryans.

Hester!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Are you combining the Offensive and Defensive rookies of the year into one honor that the NFL doesn't have?

OK Ill give defensive to Ryans. May we proceed?

Ok vote for offensvie and defensive.

offensive -- I'm still saying Bush.
defensive -- It's hard to vote against Ryans... AJ Hawk is second - he's having a hell of a season unnoticed.

I think the answer is obviously DBrick Ferguson on offense.

*Overall: Vince Young

• Offense: Young
• Defese: Hawk

Overall: Joseph Addai

Offense: Joseph Addai

Defense: Demeco Ryans

Defense:A.J. Hawk Offense: Young

You are all morons. Have this argument when the season is over. Meanwhile go count your eggs as chickens. For Instance: 2006 NFL MVP Donovan McNabb says "hi!"

Moron or not, I don't understand how any body who has been watching football over the last 8 wks cannot pick Mighty Vince Young. He is doing it all. He is doing it all by himself. He is doing it all the time. Just like at Texas. All this guy does is win. The two Saints guys can thank Drew Brees for much of their success. The defense is a little murkier. I like Devin Hester, just 'cause.

Vince Young, no contest. He's taken a team that was 4-12 last year under Steve McNair, and they're currently 6-7. A team that should be in the cellar has a good chance to finish .500 or better. Vince is 5-2 as a starter, including wins in each of his last four games. Everyone plays better with him on the field, including the defense. Everyone always talks about the "it". Vince Young has "it". He just has the ability to find the way to win, and he's doing it right now on a truly sub-par team. He doesn't have the best numbers, but skill should be measured on the ability to get the win. And by the metric, Vince Young is the best rookie out there. Hands down.

O - V Young D - AJ Hawk

O - Marques Colston D - Demeco Ryans

O - Vince Young D - Demeco Ryans (Mark Anderson's had some flashy numbers too...)

O - Vince Young

D - DeMeco Ryans

Overall - Devin Hester (Hey, I had to throw him a bone somewhere)

O: Vince Young D: A.J. Hawk

Off. - Vince Young Def. - A.J. Hawk

O: Young D: Ryans

A.J. Hawk

Overall : Jones-Drew

Offense : Vince Young

Defense : DeMeco Ryans

Offense is without a doubt vince young.hes taken a team who was 4-12 last year and are now 8-7